'Sleepless nights': Parents locked in custody battle over teen gender transition speak out
Published in News & Features
BOSTON — A high-profile Massachusetts child custody battle over a teenage girl and her request for a medical gender transition continues as her parents say the emotional impact of not being able to see their daughter has led to a broken household.
The situation has gained national media attention as Joseph and Arlene Kutzko have been denied custody of their daughter for nearly two years. They say the state took control of Sophie when she was 15 years old in December 2024 after they would not recognize her as a boy or call her by male names and pronouns, leading to a permanent restraining order against them.
“As a mom, of course, it’s not easy for me because I’m a stay-at-home mom and every time I’m alone it’s hard to imagine that my daughter is not here,” said an emotional Arlene Kutzko, adding both husband and wife have been hospitalized.
“Sleepless nights, sleepless days, worrying about our daughter. This is not the person that she is,” Joseph Kutzko told the Herald, adding that the stress of the situation has been the source of cardiac issues and has even led to doctors implanting a pacemaker into his body.
Meanwhile, Arlene was recently hospitalized following a seizure, which she says was also due to stress.
Joseph says one day in December of 2024, Sophie was staying after school for what the Kutzkos thought was to receive math tutoring, when they received a phone call from the Department of Children and Families (DCF) explaining their daughter was not coming home.
“Just so everybody is aware: Sophie was a lector at the church. She was an altar server at the Church and she led the Church in the rosaries before Mass. I mean, this kid was a very, very devout Catholic. I had no concerns about her going into this at all,” added Joseph.
The Kutzkos say Sophie’s high school — Algonquin Regional High School, in Northboro — initiated the process without their knowledge. They say a school guidance counselor had directed Sophie toward transitioning. The allegation is one the school district has “unequivocally denied.”
“Sophie left in the morning. We had never had a conversation about transgender issues or this topic at all, and she was taken from us. So we, as parents, never had the opportunity to work through this with Sophie,” the parents told the Herald.
Since that day, Joseph and Arlene have been led down a seemingly never-ending road of court appearances, restraining orders and meetings with attorneys. Immediately after DCF took custody of Sophie, a restraining order was filed against Joseph and Arlene on allegations of physical and sexual abuse. Those allegations led to no findings of guilt in both juvenile and criminal court, with the Kutzkos reaching a non-guilty disposition with prosecutors.
An attorney for the family, Vernadette Broyles says the Kutzkos reached this agreement after their legal fees exceeded $150,000, resulting in a pre-trial probation. She says the probation set on the Kutzkos will be lifted after one year as long as they commit no crimes during that period.
“When they (DCF) want to use this, what I think would probably be called lawfare, by bringing all these various legal offensive moves against a family, they can be pretty successful in doing it, because judges oftentimes will go along with this,” family attorney Greg Hessian explained. “The allegations on their face sounded bad, but as it turned out, we now know they were not true at all.”
But a charge of neglect still stands against them, allowing the restraining order to remain in place until December of this year, requiring the Kutzkos not contact Sophie during that time and do not commit any crimes.
“So there’s nothing standing, except for neglect, which we still to this day don’t even know what it (the neglect) is,” Joseph Kutzko said, saying he was even arrested the night the order was filed.
To make matters worse for the Kutzkos, Sophie, with assistance from a DCF social worker and an attorney from the Victim Rights Law Center, applied for criminal charges to be filed against Arlene for violating the restraining order currently in place. The complaint, filed in Waltham District Court, alleges Arlene violated the restraining order during a September 14 appearance on Fox News when she pleaded for Sophie to return home and expressed that she missed her.
“Please come home. Mama miss you. Please, I’m begging you,” an emotional Arlene Kutzko said when asked what she would say to Sophie if she could speak to her.
Hessian says the state has taken advantage of how the juvenile court system works when it comes to clearing accused parties of allegations of abuse against a minor.
“One of the quirks in the law that’s really snagged them and snags a lot of families is when it becomes pretty clear that the allegations were not accurate. There’s nothing in our juvenile law that allows a court to reconsider the case halfway through. There’s no off-ramp,” he explained. “The only endpoint is a trial or if the Department of Children and Families loosens their grip and says ‘yes, we’re going to send the children home by agreement.’”
Last month, a Massachusetts Juvenile Court judge blocked state officials from initiating testosterone treatments on Sophie, with the start date of a trial to determine if Joseph and Arlene can regain custody of her being pushed back to March, just weeks before Sophie turns 18 and effectively running out the clock on the court’s jurisdiction.
On top of gaining national media attention, the Kutzko’s case has drawn support from the Trump administration, with the Justice Department filing an amicus brief with the U.S. Supreme Court in September in support of parental rights as part of a lawsuit out of the state of Washington. That same week, the U.S. Department of Education launched an investigation into the Northboro-Southboro School District to determine if the district violated federal law.
“I’m not sleeping, I’m not eating, and I’m thinking about home, and my mom, in the Philippines. Every time I video chat with my mom, I have to hide because I don’t want her to see me crying,” said Arlene.
“I just want people to be aware that the school has your children all day long. You have them for a few hours after school and on the weekends. They’re working your children all the time,” Joseph said.
Joseph and Arlene are bringing their case to Capitol Hill when they testify before a congressional committee in early December on legislation to strengthen parental rights.
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at bostonherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments