City of Charlotte asks judge to dismiss Iryna Zarutska family lawsuit
Published in News & Features
CHARLOTTE, N.C. — The city of Charlotte wants a judge to dismiss entirely the wrongful death lawsuit it faces after Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska died aboard the city’s light rail train last August.
Zarutska’s uncle, who was hosting the Zarutska family in Charlotte, filed the lawsuit against the city and its transit security company, Professional Security Services, in August. The uncle and attorneys for the city and its security company met for a four-hour mediation that ended in an impasse earlier this month, according to court documents. The city responded to the uncle’s claims for the first time publicly on Monday, with a motion to dismiss filed in Mecklenburg County Superior Court.
“The City recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by Decarlos Brown Jr.,” attorneys wrote in the motion to dismiss. “The City denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack.”
Brown, a homeless man who once told police he was diagnosed with schizophrenia, stabbed Zarutska aboard the Charlotte Area Transit System’s LYNX Blue Line on Aug. 22, 2025. She died coming home from her shift at a south Charlotte pizzeria. Brown was quickly arrested and remains in federal custody. The unprovoked assault made international headlines and drew remarks from President Donald Trump.
Frank Scott Haskell, the uncle, said in his lawsuit that Zarutska’s death was preventable. The city and its security knew there were safety and crime issues related to its public transit, and they “were responsible for protecting lawful passengers from known and foreseeable dangers,” the lawsuit states. “Their failures caused the fatal stabbing.”
Simple fare enforcement, turnstiles or proper security staffing — which the city had the money for — could have saved Zarutska’s life, Haskell’s attorney, Lauren Newton, contends. The city’s light rail system is currently open, meaning there are no turnstiles at any stop, and fare enforcement isn’t rigid.
In their response, city attorneys Lori Keeton and Terry L. Wallace wrote that Brown killed Zarutska. The city has government immunity, attorneys wrote, which protects local governments from claims that stem from core functions, like law enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security-contractor oversight and public-safety administration.
If some of the claims move forward, the city asked the judge to put a $1 million limit on the amount of damages that could be owed to Zarutska’s family. The family has not said how much they are seeking.
Attorneys at odds over light rail death
In the August lawsuit against the city, Newton alleged Charlotte knew about systemic safety issues on its trains and buses. Four people died on or near the Blue Line in the year before Zarutska’s death, she wrote. A Charlotte Observer investigation found that serious assaults are much more likely to occur on buses than on trains.
In its Monday response, the city contended that “systemwide crime and incidents ... do not establish that a violent attack ... was reasonably foreseeable.” It also disputed arguments that inadequate security staffing or fare enforcement caused Zarutska’s death.
Brown did not pay for a ticket to board the light rail. There was no security on the train to step in during the assault.
North Carolina Auditor Dave Boliek earlier this year published reports revealing Charlotte’s transit system loses $6.5 million to fare evasion yearly and did not spend its full safety budget. Since Zarutska’s death, city officials have invested millions of dollars into increasing its security force on transit property.
In court documents, though, city attorneys insist that “CATS maintained an extensive security program, contracted for armed and unarmed security and company-police services, and undertook initiatives concerning public safety, security planning, training, and transit operations” before Zarutska’s death.
_____
©2026 The Charlotte Observer. Visit charlotteobserver.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments