Entertainment

/

ArcaMax

'I Play Rocky' review: Tale of a fighter playing a boxer a big-time winner

Mark Meszoros, The News-Herald (Willoughby, Ohio) on

Published in Entertainment News

Peter Farrelly is sticking with a familiar formula.

In 2018, the director — previously known for a slew of comedies co-helmed by his younger brother, Bobby, including “Dumb and Dumber” and “There’s Something About Mary” — debuted his fact-based comedy drama “Green Book” at the Toronto International Film Festival. The crowd-pleaser went on to win the best picture Academy Award in 2019.

Now, almost exactly eight years after the wide theatrical release of “Green Book” — and after a successful debut at TIFF a couple of months ago — Farrelly’s latest fact-based, crowd-pleasing comedy drama, “I Play Rocky,” is landing in theaters across the country.

The new film is a highly entertaining dramatization of then-unknown actor Sylvester Stallone’s efforts not only to see a screenplay he’d written, “Rocky,” be made into a big-screen affair but to see it made with him in the titular role of a white boxer with big dreams, Rocky Balboa.

When we meet the young version of the larger-than-life personality we’ve come to know as “Sly,” portrayed by Anthony Ippolito, he is going by Michael and is, to put it bluntly, an absolute nobody.

He is desperate to win acting gigs in New York City, and we meet him auditioning for the role of Thug No. 2.

It doesn’t go well.

We then see him in what may be the world’s worst motel room — which he can’t afford, resulting in him soon sleeping on the street — reading into a tape recorder in an effort to overcome a speech impediment tied to a partial facial paralysis from his difficult birth.

He takes a job at a movie theater, where he encounters the lovely Sasha Czack (AnnaSophia Robb). After trying to resist his, well, distinct charm, she gives in and the two start dating. He takes her to meet his gruff and combative father, Frank Stallone Sr. (Matt Dillon), whom she finds to be a highly problematic influence in Sylvester’s life. (By the way, she gets him to drop “Michael,” as she likes his real name much more.)

And after listening to him lament his inability to land a great part, she encourages him to write one for himself, as he’s demonstrated to her that he understands how movie stories are constructed.

We catch up with the couple 16 months (and eight screenplays) later in Los Angeles. His work as a writer eventually piques the interest of producing partners Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne, “The Wolf of Wall Street”) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell, “For All Mankind”), but he hasn’t yet brought them something they feel they can take to a studio.

That changes after a fateful visit to a bar, where Sly gets pulled into watching the televised fight between heavyweight champion Muhammad Ali and seemingly unworthy underdog Chuck Wepner — a contest staged in Northeast Ohio at the old Richfield Coliseum.

He rushes home, and a few largely sleep-deprived days later, he has a script that dazzles Irwin and Robert, who imagine getting an established star to portray the pugilistic protagonist.

No, he says in the first of many utterances of the titular line.

“I play Rocky.”

They try to convince him that won’t happen, an idea hammered home by Sandy Maddox (a compilation of several studio executives played with great gusto by Tracy Letts).

 

We don’t want to offer much more about the plot, but let’s just say it’s difficult to move Sly off this position, as hard as Sandy, via Irwin and Robert, tries.

Of course, we know that our hero will, in fact, play Rocky and that the movie will open in 1976 and go on to do well at the box office and earn its share of awards. That doesn’t make it any less fun to take in this film’s re-creation of its low-budget and, relatedly, pressure-packed shoot.

Another standout supporting player is Jay Duplass (“Other Mommy”), who embodies the late John G. Avildsen, hired to direct the film because he has a history of keeping productions on track — and despite the fact that boxing scenes completely bore him.

Stephan James (“If Beale Street Could Talk”), too, brings some heat as another important deceased contributor, the colorful Carl Weathers, beloved for his portrayal of rival boxer Apollo Creed.

And while Robb (“Rebel Ridge”) must be praised, too, for her deft work as Sly’s loyal but sometimes understandably frustrated better half, we’ve gone too long here without lauding the work of Ippolito. Until now best known for convincingly portraying Al Pacino in “The Offer,” Paramount’s limited series dramatizing the making of another classic film, “The Godfather,” the actor’s take on Stallone is a treasure. The voice, the mannerisms, the heart — it’s all on the screen.

The relatively little-known screenwriter Peter Gamble is responsible for the strong script, and the project has benefited from the participation of Stallone, who, while not a producer on “I Play Rocky,” provided Farrelly with lots of details from that all-important time in his life, according to the film’s production notes.

It’s not that everything the post-”Mary” Farrelly touches turns to gold; in 2022, his “The Greatest Beer Run Ever” — another based-on-a-true-story comedy drama that debuted at TIFF — didn’t exactly set the world on fire.

It’s hard to say whether “I Play Rocky” has even a puncher’s chance at Oscar glory, but, as the movie reminds us, the world loves a good underdog story.

———

‘I PLAY ROCKY’

3.5 stars (out of 4)

MPA rating: PG-13 (for strong language, brief sexual material, and smoking)

Running time: 2:08

How to watch: In theaters nationwide Nov. 20

———


©2026 The News-Herald (Willoughby, Ohio). Visit The News-Herald (Willoughby, Ohio) at www.news-herald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus