Current News

/

ArcaMax

Chicago aldermen introduce ordinance allowing outside investigation of city finances after CFO exit

Alice Yin and Jake Sheridan, Chicago Tribune on

Published in News & Features

CHICAGO — City Council opponents of Mayor Brandon Johnson plan to introduce an ordinance this week to let the Finance Committee chair authorize an independent investigation of the city’s finances, the first attempt by aldermen to wrest control of the fallout from Johnson’s CFO suddenly resigning last week.

Alderman Pat Dowell, 3rd, and others will propose the legislation that would give her the ability to select an outside firm to investigate possible misreporting of Chicago’s financial information, according to a draft copy obtained by the Tribune. The council members put the measure forward after CFO Ashlee Gabrysch’s stunning exit on Friday, when she cited a refusal to compromise her integrity, sent shock waves through City Hall.

“In the wake of last week’s resignation of the city’s third CFO in a year, we find ourselves at a moment where every effort must be made to secure the public’s confidence in our city’s finances,” Dowell said in a statement Monday. “I joined 11 other members of City Council today in sponsoring an ordinance calling for an independent, impartial and comprehensive review of city finances, financial reporting and statements made by this administration to investors, Council, and the public over the last three years. We must ensure the reliability of these statements associated with the city’s financial condition, revenues, expenditures, and other obligations.”

It’s the latest sign that the ongoing controversy is here to stay as aldermen already entrenched against Johnson attempt to force scrutiny onto his administration and pressure Johnson into bearing the responsibility for sure-to-be-unpopular spending cuts they argue the city needs. And amid the fray at City Hall, virtually every mayoral candidate has used the messy resignation to criticize the mayor.

The firm would be chosen by Dowell, a Johnson opponent, and report directly to her. It would essentially be given power to request documents from any city employee and department, and anyone who did not comply would be subject to discipline, including suspension or dismissal. The investigation would be funded from the Finance Committee’s budget.

Johnson’s press office did not immediately comment on the proposed ordinance, but it seems inconceivable the mayor would be on board with giving Dowell the power to oversee a wide-ranging audit into city finances. It’s likely to become the latest showdown between the fifth floor and council, one that could turn into a politically damaging battle for Johnson amid his fourth budget fight.

Aldermen plan to introduce the ordinance to the council Wednesday and seek to suspend the rules in order to vote on it immediately. They would need 34 votes to overcome an expected mayoral veto, a difficult hurdle.

And even with supermajority support, aldermen could still face hurdles if Johnson contends only he has the power to enter into city contracts and simply refuses to move ahead, a stance he took in 2024 when a veto-proof majority of aldermen sought to determine the ShotSpotter police response tool’s future.

Asked Monday morning why she believes the City Council has the power to launch an outside review, Dowell was brief. “It’s written in law,” she said, before later sending messages pointing to several specific cases she believes granted aldermen the authority.

Dowell said she would like to hire a review firm “as soon as possible,” but declined to say how long hiring could take and if she expects to get and use feedback as City Hall crafts a budget.

Gabrysch stepped down Friday after just three months on the job due to concerns over how the city was representing financial information, sparking alarm throughout City Hall as she outlined in her resignation letter: “I am not able to fulfill those obligations under the conditions in which I have been asked to serve.” Dowell immediately called for an audit as Johnson’s statement sought to point the finger back at Gabrysch and threatened to report her to the inspector general, before Johnson walked that back on Saturday.

Last month, Gabrysch raised internal concerns about the city’s deficit reporting and characterization of the settlement borrowing, according to emails obtained by the Tribune. Johnson’s budget team estimated next year’s budget gap at $882 million in the deficit forecast rollout in September before rolling out an “adjusted” $652 million figure largely attributed to plans to borrow for the cost of police settlements.

Johnson claimed 76% of his gap-filling proposals were structural, but Gabrysch publicly broke with his administration and said structural solutions only made up 56% of the mayor’s proposal. Before that, she informed Johnson’s senior leadership team how she would be presenting the information.

“I will not use campaign framing or political messaging in my testimony. Doing so would be inconsistent with my fiduciary responsibility as Chief Financial Officer and could put the City in legal jeopardy,” Gabrysch wrote.

 

Johnson’s press secretary, Allison Novelo, said in a Friday statement that the administration has been clear about the cost of settlements as well as the scope of the deficit and the city’s intention to borrow in its public budget overview documents and presentations to the City Council.

The mayor, in a campaign event on Saturday, added: “My budget is a fair budget. It’s a balanced budget. And again, I can’t speak to any of her claims or assertions.”

Dowell and aldermen across the council’s ideological spectrum declined to say Monday whether they supported the $480 million borrowing plan, a sign of the enormous unanswered questions lingering over budget negotiations as City Hall’s attention turns away from questions of policy toward questions of trust.

Several moderate aldermen said their trust was damaged, but they remained unsure of what to make of the controversy.

“I still just don’t have an understanding of what happened. Like, I want an investigation,” said Alderman Timmy Knudsen, a middle-of-the-council alderman Johnson likely hoped to flip into a budget supporter.

Close Johnson ally Alderman William Hall, 6th, declined to say whether his trust in the mayor had been harmed, adding that he didn’t “know all the facts.”

“It’s literally been 72 hours,” he said. “What I do know is that December 31st will be here sooner than later. And I don’t want to go into the absolute last few weeks of the year trying to vote on the budget that my residents are looking forward to (me) delivering.”

Meanwhile, seemingly every candidate in the crowded field gunning for Johnson’s job was quick to condemn Gabrysch’s departure as a sign of the mayor’s shortcomings.

Illinois Comptroller Susana Mendoza blasted the resignation on Instagram as a “five-alarm financial crisis.” Lobbyist John Kelly called it “deeply troubling” in a Friday statement. More digs came in from businessman Willie Wilson, Cook County Board of Review Commissioner George Cardenas, Chicago Housing Authority board member Matthew Brewer, U.S. Rep. Mike Quigley, attorney Bill Quinlan and entrepreneur Joe Holberg.

And asked what was “going well” in Johnson’s administration during a Sunday talk-show appearance in Logan Square, Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias instead started with what wasn’t.

“We keep on losing CFOs every week,” he said to laughs. “We’ve got a lot of challenges.”

_____


©2026 Chicago Tribune. Visit chicagotribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus