Defense rests in Haiti presidential killing trial after Sanon's cross-examination
Published in News & Features
MIAMI — Christian Emmanuel Sanon continued to deny any involvement in the July 7, 2021, assassination of Haitian President Jovenel Moïse, insisting Monday that four men convicted earlier this year in the plot had shut him out and severed ties with him weeks before the president was shot to death inside his bedroom.
After two days of testimony in his own defense, Sanon spent Monday pushing back on prosecutors’ efforts to portray him as a politically ambitious “con artist at the end of his rope” who repeatedly lied about his medical credentials and was so desperate to become Haiti’s president he “hired Colombian mercenaries” and claimed to have State Department backing.
The U.S. government support, prosecutors argued through the trial and tried to show in their cross-examination, was one of many lies he told as he conspired to kidnap and kill a head of state. Sanon didn’t just conspire to overthrow Moïse’s government, he also provided material support in the form of himself, a squad of Colombian former soldiers and bulletproof vests, said the government, which describes his crime as the desperate vengeful acts of a greedy, 68-year-old man who was jealous of Moïse.
Sanon’s defense, which rested after his testimony, has focused on messages showing that the group was hiding information from him. They’ve also challenged the credibility of the government’s witnesses, questioning their credibility — and the text messages the government presented.
Sanon faces a total of eight charges in the updated indictment filed against him in September. The most serious charges are conspiring to kill or kidnap a person outside the United States, namely Haiti’s president, and conspiring to provide material support to cause his death. Each of those three counts carries up to life in prison.
In addition, Sanon is charged with two counts of conspiring to commit an offense against the United States, participating in a military expedition against Haiti, a friendly nation of the United States, smuggling ballistic vests from the United States to Haiti and submitting false or misleading information on export forms.
The burden in the case rests on the government, which must prove Sanon is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. At the heart of their case is demonstrating that Sanon is a con artist who has misled people for years to believe he’s a mover and shaker, a visionary and purported doctor.
Although Sanon claimed he had once practiced medicine in Missouri, Illinois, New York and Florida, he acknowledged he was not licensed to practice anywhere in the United States when Assistant U.S. Attorney Altanese Phenelus confronted him with a resume he had submitted to the South Florida Baptist Convention.
“I am a physician, but I was not practicing medicine,” he said.
When Phenelus presented records showing that he had once listed his apartment address as the place where he practiced medicine, Sanon replied, “That was wrong. That was my address.”
Throughout the trial prosecutors have tried to establish Sanon’s connection to four South Florida men convicted in May in the sprawling conspiracy. They tried to counter his defense that by the time Moïse, 53, was killed, Sanon, a Boynton Beach resident and Haitian-American pastor, had been sidestepped by the group in favor of Haitian Superior Court Justice Windelle Coq Thélot.
During the cross-examination, Phenelus sought to punch holes in both that defense and Sanon’s credibility by confronting him with contradictions in his testimony, and with the government’s trove of text messages, including WhatsApp exchanges between him and some of the convicted conspirators.
“On Saturday, May 23, you and your team had a plan to overthrow the Moïse government and install you as president, correct, Mr. Sanon?” Phenelus asked, referring to a text message from Arcángel Ortiz Pretel, one of the men convicted in May and the owner of the Doral security firm that hired the Colombians.
“No, we did not have a plan,” Sanon replied.
While Sanon has repeatedly claimed his only motivation was to help Haiti, Phenelus tried to tie him to his alleged efforts to secure an expensive house, a luxury fleet of cars and what prosecutors assert was a scheme to replace Moïse in order to get lucrative security and infrastructure contracts in Haiti.
“During your direct examination last week, you also said that you just wanted to help Haiti and that you didn’t care about living in a big, comfortable house,” Phenelus said. “Do you remember that testimony?“
After Sanon said he did, Phenelus asked him about text messages in 2021 showing him searching for a property before confronting him with a May 30 email to Walter Veintemilla. The email to the Broward County financier, who was also convicted in the conspiracy, was about a $2.5 million house in the Pacot neighborhood of Port-au-Prince.
“It was a beautiful property,” Sanon replied.
Throughout their tense exchange, Phenelus sought to show that Sanon’s actions were inconsistent with the image he tried to present to the 12-member jury. While he acknowledged certain details, he repeatedly rejected the conclusions she drew.
During the testimony, he acknowledged friendships with Coq Thélot, as well as the former coordinator of the Presidential Security Unit, Jean Laguel Civil, who was arrested in Haiti in connection to the plot, and Jacmel Mayor Marky Kessa. Kessa remains jailed after most of the prisoners arrested in connection to the plot escaped during a jailbreak.
None of those relationships, Sanon said, had anything to do with trying to seize power from Moïse.
Defense rested
Sanon’s defense presented just two witnesses: Sanon and a forensics expert who challenged the government’s evidence extracted from Sanon’s cellphones and other defendants indicted in the sprawling case.
The text messages, emails and voice notes have been central to the government’s case, and were at the center of the tense back and forth as Phenelus attempted to use them to show Sanon’s continued ties to the plotters.
“I was not in communication with them about what decision they made, who they decided,” he testified about being sidelined for Coq Thélot. “And then here, I’m seeing what they call me … They call me all kinds of things.”
More than once, he challenged the assistant prosecutor to show that he had either read messages or present him with the entire chat beyond his membership in a chat group.
“You’re active in this group,” Phenelus said as she displayed one of the exchanges.
“Could you show it to me that I read it,” Sanon then said, before she became flustered and moved on to another line of questioning.
Trying to build on his assertions about being sidestepped by the men and some of the Colombians, Phenelus said, “You testified, Mr. Sanon, with your defense attorney … that you were cut out of this conspiracy.”
Sanon rejected the characterization that he had been “cut off from this conspiracy.” He insisted that he had testified that as of June 10 the group had dropped him for Coq Thélot.
“This is the new president,” Sanon recalled hearing.
“That’s all I said, but not conspiracy,” he added. “I don’t know about the word conspiracy.”
Throughout the cross, Phenelus pressed Sanon on why, if he believed he had lost the men’s support to replace Moïse, he did not alert authorities or return home to Florida.
“I told you I was home,” he shot back during one of the exchanges.
“I’m living in Haiti, I’m in a house in Haiti, I’m working in Haiti, so there is no reason for me to run because of the death of the president or because somebody has their own … ideas,” he said, claiming to be a resident of both Haiti and the United States.
During another exchange, he again was confronted with his earlier testimony.
“You stayed in Haiti the entire time, right?... Sleeping in someone’s house.... Eating someone else’s food?” the prosecutor asked while accusing Sanon of living off of other people’s money while being guarded by Colombian commandos.
“I don’t know what you mean,” Sanon said, one of many instances where he feigned like he did not understand her question.
Throughout the questioning Sanon remained largely calm, even as Phenelus tried to draw him out on his “attitude toward Moïse,” and show he had a disdain for the unpopular president.
When she confronted him about referring to Moïse a week before his assassination as “the rat,” Sanon said “that’s the word they were using among the Colombians.”
He claimed that the messages she was pulling out were things that had been forwarded to him, which he in turn forwarded to keep people abreast of what was happening in Haiti. Their exchanges at times resembled a verbal sparring match.
After presenting other images, Phenelus then played a video in Haitian Creole featuring a caricature of Moïse glued to a chair, his pants stuck to the seat — a mocking reference of him intending to stay in power until February 2022.
Without waiting for a question, Sanon explained what the narrator had said, drawing chuckles from inside the courtroom of mostly Haitian onlookers.
Phenelus then opened a final image from the electronic messages. This one depicted the slain president’s face on a Campbell’s soup can.
“That’s the foreign minister next to him,” Sanon said without being prompted or asked a question.
“You refer to President Moïse as a cream of bulls—t, right?” Phenelus asked, referring to the wording on the image.
“That’s what the image said,” Sanon replied
©2026 Miami Herald. Visit at miamiherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments